Step by step
Gold: the cells the step is aboutPink outline: newly placed in this step
STEP 1Barnaby stands in the top left
Clues used- Barnaby Trevelyan stood in a corner of the board.
- Barnaby Trevelyan was in the conservatory.
Clue 4 names the corners. Those are (1,1) in the conservatory, (1,5) in the drawing room, (5,1) in the library and (5,5) in the drawing room. Clue 5 says Barnaby was in the conservatory. Only the top-left corner lies there, so Barnaby stands on (1,1).
ConservatoryB
Drawing room
Library
STEP 2Adelaide stands next to the rug, top right
Clues used- Adelaide Whitcombe stood next to a rug.
The rug is in the top-right corner, on (1,5). Next to it are (1,4) and (2,5). The top row already has Barnaby, so only (2,5) is left for Adelaide.
ConservatoryB
Drawing room
A
Library
STEP 3Eleanor has two options
Clues used- Eleanor Vane stood next to a palm.
The palm is on (5,4). Next to it are (4,4), (5,3) and (5,5). The right-hand column already has Adelaide, so (4,4) and (5,3) are left for Eleanor. That is not conclusive yet, so we note both cells as candidates (small E).
ConservatoryB
Drawing room
A
Library
E
E
STEP 4Dudley has two options
Clues used- Dudley Penhallow stood next to a bookshelf.
The bookshelves are on (3,2) and (4,1). Next to them are (2,2), (3,1), (5,1) and (3,3), (4,2). Of these, (2,2) drops out because that row already has Adelaide, (3,1) is a blocked table, and (5,1) is in Barnaby’s column. That leaves (3,3) and (4,2) for Dudley.
ConservatoryB
Drawing room
A
Library
D
D
E
E
STEP 5 · THE KEYThe weapons decide
Clues used- Dudley Penhallow had the brass candlestick on them.
- Eleanor Vane had the small poison bottle on them.
No cell helps here any more, but the weapons do. Suppose Dudley stands on (4,2). Then row 4 is taken, and Eleanor is left with only (5,3). They would both be in the library, so the brass candlestick and the small poison bottle would both have to lie in the library. But each room holds at most one weapon, so that is impossible. So Dudley stands on (3,3). That takes column 3, and Eleanor stands on (4,4) in the drawing room. In the notebook you now record: the brass candlestick lies in the library (with Dudley), the small poison bottle lies in the drawing room (with Eleanor).
Thought experiment: Dudley on (4,2), Eleanor on (5,3). Both in the library, which is impossible.
ConservatoryB
Drawing room
A
Library
D
E
So: Dudley on (3,3), Eleanor on (4,4) in the drawing room.
ConservatoryB
Drawing room
A
Library
D
E
Notebook after step 5 | Conservatory | Drawing room | Library |
|---|
| Brass candlestick | | | ✓ |
|---|
| Small poison bottle | | ✓ | |
|---|
| Coiled rope | | | |
|---|
× = ruled out, ✓ = lies there
STEP 6Cecily gets the last cell
Row 5 and column 2 are left. Cecily stands on (5,2).
ConservatoryB
Drawing room
A
Library
D
E
C
STEP 7The notebook fills up
The coiled rope cannot be in the library or the drawing room, because each already holds a weapon. That leaves the conservatory: ✓. All other cells are ×.
Notebook after step 7 | Conservatory | Drawing room | Library |
|---|
| Brass candlestick | × | × | ✓ |
|---|
| Small poison bottle | × | ✓ | × |
|---|
| Coiled rope | ✓ | × | × |
|---|
× = ruled out, ✓ = lies there
STEP 8The solution
The victim, Eleanor, stands in the drawing room, so that is the scene of the crime. The only other person in the drawing room is Adelaide, so she is the culprit. The small poison bottle lies in the drawing room, so that is the murder weapon. The accusation reads: “Adelaide Whitcombe, in the drawing room, with the small poison bottle.”
ConservatoryB
Drawing room
A
Library
D
E
C
The key tip
If the victim has a weapon “on them”, that is the murder weapon straight away. You do not have to place every weapon, the one in the room of the crime is enough.